#*#*#*#  (C) 2000-2005, RashiYomi Inc. Dr Hendel President #*#*#*#
  -----------------------------------------------------------
  |      Rashi is Simple Version 2.0                         |
  |      (C) RashiYomi Inc., Dr Hendel President             |
  |       http://www.RashiYomi.Com                           |
  | PERMISSION to reprint WITH this header if NOT for profit |
  ------------------------------------------------------------


VERSE: Lv06-23b

=================== Lv06-23b ================================

SUCCINCT SUMMARY
----------------
One of Rashis 5 main tasks is to explain meaning.  Rashi had
10 vehicles to explain meaning. Rashi would sometimes show
the meaning of CONNECTIVE WORDS such as ALSO, IF, WHEN, ALL
etc. We call this this the Rashi method and submethod of
SPECIAL CONNECTIVE WORDS

Today we examine the meaning of the word ALL. ALL has
5 biblical usages. They are summarized in LIST005n below.
a) ALL = NO INDIVIDUAL EXCEPTIONS,
b) ALL = No CLASS EXCEPTIONS
c) ALL = EMPHASIS: EVEN borderline cases
d) ALL = ALL parts
e) ALL X= ALL members of Xs group (X is an example)

Today we examine usage (e). Lets clarify it with
an English example:  Suppose I say
----------------------------------------------
When taking a person to a hospital ALL red-light
prohibitions are suspended
----------------------------------------------

We can interpret this sentence as follows
----------------------------------------------
When taking a person to a hospital ALL traffic
prohibitions are suspended
----------------------------------------------

In other words RED LIGHTS are simply a good
example of what is suspended (since going
thru a red light has a high likelihood of
causing an accident (more so than speeding).

We could summarize this with the following
translation
----------------------------------------------
When taking a person to a hospital ALL traffic
prohibitions-like red lights--are suspended
----------------------------------------------

An alternative approach to this usage of ALL
is to regard ALL as a word of emphasis indicating
generalization.


EXAMPLE Lv06-23b ALL
--------------------
Lv06-23b states
-----------------------------------------------
ALL sin offerings whose blood is brought into
the Temple proper become invalid and may not be eaten
------------------------------------------------

Rashi comments
----------------------------------
The word ALL includes other sacrifices (Whose blood
is brought into the TEMPLE proper) In other words
if ANY sacrifice has its blood  brought into the
temple then it becomes invalid
----------------------------------

Thus Rashi translated Lv06-23b as follows:

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Invalidate all SACRIFICES (-like sin offerings) whose blood
is brought inside
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Here is the argument for using SIN OFFERINGS as an example
    - Certain sin offerings are done INSIDE the temple (Lv16)
    - Hence I might interpret the invalidation of outside-sin
      offerings whose blood is brought INSIDE as a prohibition
      based on a confusion of sin offerings(i.e. it makes
      ordinary sin offerings look like inside-sin offerings)
    - But if a certain offering type does not have INSIDE
      OFFERINGS I would not have thought it invalidated if
      its blood is brought inside (Because there is nothing
      to confuse it with)
    - Hence the word ALL includes in this invalidation even
      non-sin offerings that do NOT have a counterpart--if
      any offering is brought inside it is invalidated.

As noted several times in this email list
this usage of ALL has a MIDRASHIC
flavor since since the reader must have a knowledge of
other areas of Jewish law.

The reader who is not happy with the above translation
can use our alternative approach and regard ALL as
a word of EMPHASIS indicating GENERALIZATION.

LIST005n below presents many Rashis on the word ALL
which has 5 usages.
=============================================================
ITEM                     DETAIL
======================= =====================================
RASHI RULE CLASS:        SPECIAL CONNECTIVE WORDS
RASHI SUBRULE CLASS      CONNECTIVE WORDS
RASHI WORKBOOK PRINCIPLE #8
SEE BELOW                LIST005n
List of                  5 meanings of ALL (KOL)
=============================================================

============================ LIST005n =============================
List of                  5 meanings of ALL (KOL)
===================================================================
VERSE    TEXT WITH "ALL"            INCLUDES EVEN THE FOLLOWING
======== ========================== ===============================
Gn06-12a ALL FLESH became corrupted EVEN ANIMALS were corrupted*27
Gn07-14a ALL Winged creatures       EVEN Grasshoppers with wings
Lv11-42b ALL crawling on belly      EVEN Snails who crawl*1
Lv11-42c ALL walking on claws       EVEN beetles who crawl*2
Nu21-08b ANYONE Bitten was cured    EVEN Dogbites*3
Lv17-12a ALL shouldn't eat blood    EVEN Minors shouldn't eat*4
Lv19-02a Speak to ALL Jews          EVEN speak to MINORS*5
Nu18-09c ALL pure priests may eat   EVEN your wives may eat
Nu20-29b ALL mourned Aaron          EVEN women mourned*6
-------  ------------------------   ---------------------------
Gn21-06a ALL happy on Sarah's birth EVEN other barren women*32
Lv24-14a ALL hearing the Blasphemy  EVEN the judges *7 *28
Nu14-01a The WHOLE nation rebelled  EVEN the LEADERS *8 *28
Lv14-09a Cut ALL hair               EVEN non-dense hair *9
Ex12-43b ALL foreigners             EVEN Jewish apostates *10
Dt20-11a ALL conquered willbe yours EVEN from other nations *11
Ex12-12b I-ll smite all 1stborn     EVEN from other nations *11
Gn43-09b I-ll owe you my WHOLE life EVEN in the next world
Dt13-01a Listen to ALL commandments EVEN the light ones
Lv11-33b ALL inside will be impure  EVEN if hanging in the air*16
-------  ------------------------   ----------------------------
Gn19-04b ALL Sedomites gathered     NO EXCEPTIONS *29
Gn33-11d I have EVERYTHING I need   WITHOUT EXCEPTION*12
Ex19-11c The WHOLE nation saw God   NO BLIND(Exceptions)
Ex32-26b ALL Levites came           NO levite served calf
Dt01-01b Moses spoke to ALL Israel  ALL Came; no exception*13
Dt11-06a Earthquake in ALL Israel   TREMORS at all locations
Lv22-05d To ANY human uncleanlines  Dead humans,Lepors,Zavs etc
-------  ------------------------   ----------------------------
Lv21-11b Don't defile on ANY dead   even body PARTS(organs) *30
Lv27-09a ANYthing Dedicated is holy even animal PARTS(Organs)
Lv02-13b SALT all offerings         even the ORGAN PARTS
Lv06-11b ANYTHING touching is holy  even PART of it*14
Ex12-20b Dont eat ANY leaven        even PART LEAVEN(Mixture)
Lv03-03a & Offer ALL fat            even fat of PARTS(organs)
Lv04-07a Spill ANY blood            even leftover droplets*15
-------  ------------------------   ----------------------------
Ex35-22a Bzalel did ALL God ordered Even if Moses forgot*17 *31
Nu20-01a WHOLE nation came to Tzn   Even adult men over 21*18
Nu18-09b Priests get ALL sacrifices EVEN Peace offerings*19
Lv17-10a ALL eating blood will die  Even non sacrificial blood*20
Lv06-11a ALL male priests eat it    Even blemished ones*21
Dt18-01a ALL priests won-t inherit  EVEN blemished ones*22
Lv06-32b ALL sin offerings          EVEN Guilt Offerings*23
Lv06-23b ALL sin offerings          EVEN other sacrifices*33
Dt14-11a ALL Kosher birds eatable   EVEN sent-away leporbird*24
Ex12-47a ALL Jews offer on Passover By Individual not family*25
Ex01-22a ALL children die in river  EVEN Egyptian Children*26

NOTES
-----
*1 Rashi gives examples: "CRAWLING ON BELLY" could refer to
   a SNAKE. "ALL WHO CRAWL ON BELLY" refers to SNAILS
   Thus the ALL includes even insects

*2 Rashi gives examples: "WALKING ON CLAWS" refers to the
   scoprion---"ALL WHO WALK ON CLAWS" refers to the BEETLES

*3 Rashi further FURTHER supports this with the alignment
  (The Torah is speaking about a plague of BITING SNAKES
  God told Moses to make a copper snake and those that look
  at it would live) Consider the alignment of the following
  verses

  ---------------------------------------------------------------
  Nu21-08 And ANYONE Bitten            will  SEE      it & live
  Nu21-09 And ANYONE Bitten by a snake would STARE at it & live
                                *1            *2
  ---------------------------------------------------------------

  Thus if a SNAKE bit them they had to STARE at it to live
  But if a  DOG   bit them they could just see it and live

  Finally, Rashi in the name of the Talmud explains why "looking"
  at a copper snake should cure---it symbolically referred to
  "looking upwards and praying"


*4 That is the adults should TRAIN minors not to eat blood

*5 This Rashi, besides being derived from the word ALL is further
   supported by an alignment of introductory verses

   ---------------------------------------------
   Lv15-01 speak to     the              Jews
   Lv12-02 Speak to     the              Jews
   Lv19-02 Speak to ALL the community of Jews
                    *a         *b
   ---------------------------------------------

   Thus there is an emphasis that the whole community should
   hear (even children)


*6 Again Rashi is supported by an alignment

        -----------------------------------------------------
        Dt34-08 the       children    of Israel mourned Moses
        Nu20-29 the whole house       of Israel Mourned Aaron
                     *a    *b
        -----------------------------------------------------

   The term HOUSE of ISRAEL is more
   directed to women and children


*7 ALL people (even judges who heard testimony) must stone
   the blasphemer

*8 ALL people cried at hearing the spies story (Even the
   leaders)

*9 Thru the GENERAL PARTICULAR GENERAL principle we learn
   that only dense-visible hair (like eyebrows) has to
   be shaved. This is learned by generalizing the examples
   in the verse ("head", "beard", "eyebrows")

   Thru the word "ALL" we learn that even non-dense or
   non-visible hair (like armpit hair or outer-arm-hair)
   should be shaved.

   Thus the two items--GENERAL-PARTICULAR-GENERAL and ALL
   teach us that ALL is shaved except NOSE-HAIR


*10 Neither foreigners nor Jewish Apostates can bring offerings

*11 Thus eg God smote the Firstborn of Egyptians and also the
   firstborn of other nations who were visiting Egypt


*12 This was incorrectly translated in a previous posting

*13 Rashi points out the subtlety in this: People normally act
   macho--they would say "If I had been there to hear Moses I
   would have answered him". Therefore it says ALL Israel..
   Moses made sure "EVERYBODY" was there so that no one
   should claim that "I would have answered Moses".

*14 This law is beneficial--if the sacrifice touched other
   meat then ONLY THE PLACE WHERE IT TOUCHED has to be cut off
   (Only PART of it is holy)

   Rashi further learns that TOUCHING does not confer holiness
   unless there was ABSORPTION of the meat flavor (According
   to Malbim this is learned from order of words--this will
   be discussed in another posting)

*15 So you spill the blood out of the cup--then you vigorously
   shake it and spill the leftover droplets (hence ALL the blood
   is spilt)

*16 So eg if the dead organ fell into the cup then anything
   in the AIRSPACE of the cup becomes ritually impure EVEN
   if it is not touching the cup but eg suspended

   In legal terminology we say that (BEING) INSIDE is a
   VEHICLE for TRANSMISSION of impurity in earthenware cups

*17 I would logically think that Bzalel couldn't do things that
   God told Moses but Moses forgot to tell Bzalel.

   Rashi brings a possible example--In Ex25 Moses orders the
   temple utensils to be built first and then the Tabernacle

   But in Ex36 and Ex37 Bzalel builds the Tabernacle first
   and then the temple.

   Logically Bzalel knew that you build the house first and
   then fill it with utensils

*18 Nu14-29 states that the adult males over 20 who listened to
   the spies slander of Israel died. However they had all
   died by the time they came to Tzin---hence the WHOLE
   community came (because they didn't bury anyone in the
   previous place)

*19 Nu18-09 lists 3 types of sacrifices that priests get.
   It does not list peace offerings. HEnce I need the word
   ALL to include it. This is further indicated in Lv06
   and Lv07-23.

*20 It says Lv17-11 that the reason blood is prohibited is
   because it is used to atone on the altar

   Hence it is logical to conclude that only sacrificial
   blood is forbidden but ordinary blood that can't be
   offered is permissable. Therefore the verse says ALL BLOOD
   to include this other blood.

*21,*22 It explicitly says (Lv22--21:22) that blemished priests
      may not offer sacrifices (But may eat them).

      Hence the word "ALL" includes even blemished priests--
      since they can't offer sacrifices I might think they
      DO inherit Israel--I might also think that they do
      not join the Priestly rotations (which offer and eat
      the sacrifices).

      Therefore the word ALL is used. They

      do join the priestly rotations,
      do not inherit Israeli land,
      do not offer sacrifices
      do eat them

*23 There are 3 opinions of what the word ALL includes.
   The best literary approach is to use Lv07-07
   "The sin offering is like the guilt offering"
   (Since both sin and guilt offerings deal with matters
   of sin) Thus the word "ALL sin offerings" includes
   even guilt all offerings.

   We used this Rashi to show Rashis literary style.
   See above


*24 Recall that most sacrifices are HOLY and cannot be eaten
   even if they are Kosher. Further recall that the Lepor
   was atoned by having a Kosher bird sent away and another
   one offered (Lv14-04:07). I might think that this
   sent-away-Lepor bird is like any other sacrificial object
   and prohibited from eating. Therefore Dt14-11 says
   "ALL Kosher birds..." may be eaten--even the Kosher lepor
   bird.



*25  The first passover offering has one lamb PER family(Ex12-03)
    Hence I might think that future passover offerings are
    PER family. Therefore when Ex12-16 says "The WHOLE community
    must offer it" it means EVERY individual

*26 Added Dec 27, 2001. This verse discusses how Pharoh
    decreed death on all children.

    The Bible explicitly says that Egypt was run by
    magicians and stargazers (Ex07-11, Ex08-15). It
    therefore seems reasonable that they told Pharoh that
    they were told my magic that a savior was born to the Jews
    Since Pharoh didnt know if the savior was Egyptian or Jewish
    Pharoh ordered ALL children -- EVEN Egyptian children --
    killed by drowning.

*27 In this part of the list ALL means ALL SUBGROUPS

*28 In this part of the list ALL means EVEN BORDERLINE CASES
    So eg THE WHOLE NATION REBELS includes EVEN THE LEADERS
    (Since you wouldnt expect the leaders to rebel)

*29 In this part of the list ALL means WITHOUT EXCEPTION
    (Everybody)

*30 In this part of the list ALL means ALL PARTS (eg
    even ORGANS)


*31 In this part of the list ALL refers EVEN to items
    you dont EXPECT (Hence this part of the list is
    MIDRASHIC in flavor).  For example BEZALEL did ALL
    GOD COMMANDED MOSES...the word ALL refers EVEN to
    items that Moses forgot (Since you wouldnt think
    that Bezalel followed forgotten orders)

*32 (Rashi) The other BARREN women hearing about Sarah's birth
    were happy because they gave birth also.

*33 The argument goes for using sin offering as an example
    is as follows:
    - Certain sin offeringts are done INSIDE the temple (Lv16)
    - Hence I might interpret the invalidation of outside-sin
      offerings whose blood is brought INSIDE as a prohibition
      based on a confusion of sin offerings(i.e. it makes
      ordinary sin offerings look like inside-sin offerings)
    - But if a certain offering type does not have INSIDE
      OFFERINGS I would not have thought it invalidated if
      its blood is brought inside (Because there is nothing
      to confuse it with)
    - Hence the word ALL includes in this invalidation even
      non-sin offerings that do NOT have a counterpart--if
      any offering is brought inside it is invalidated.

    - We could therefore retranslate this verse with the
      emphasis on ALL as follows
      -------------------------------------------------
      And ALL -- (like a sin offering that has a counterpart
     inside and we are worried about confusing the two)--ALL whose
      blood is brought into the temple --they become invalid
     -----------------------------------------------------
===================================================================
---------------------------------------------------
WARNING: The following additional references may be too wordy
However they frequently contain additional information & lists
The hyperlinks only work on the main website

Volume 25 Number 5


#*#*#*#  (C) 2000-2005, RashiYomi Inc. Dr Hendel President #*#*#*#
Volume 25 Number 5